Double Trouble: or Why I think Free Feeding Dogs is a Questionable Practice.


August 21, 2015 by The Dog Rules

SomeonePoopedintheHallI was asked to take care of a couple of little, toy breed dogs while their family is on vacation. Fortunately for me they are to stay in their own home and the schedule is pretty much that to which they are accustomed.

In going over any special instructions or care with the owner I learned that these dogs are accustomed to having food available all the time. Feeding them  sounds so simple doesn’t it? All I need to do is scoop that dog chow out of the bag and into their shared bowl. Put down a bowl of fresh water and they’re all taken care of. What could be easier?

Free feeding could be considered the easiest method of all. Simply keep the food bowl topped up and allow the dog to eat as much and when he chooses. Other than taking him outside a few times for a walk or a potty break, this is easy peasy dog care. Why then is there such a controversy about Free Feeding versus Scheduled Feeding Times?

What are the advantages of Free Feeding?

Food is freely available so that the dog can eat whenever he is hungry.

The theory is that dogs will only eat as much as they need according to whether or not they are hungry; however, this does not apply to all dogs.

Feeding feeding is more certainly more convenient for the owner as they simply need to top up the food bowl when it is running low.

Some advocates of free feeding believe that this method reduces or eliminates food related aggression. I have never seen a study proving this theory.

The disadvantages?

Free feeding can lead to obesity and obesity related diseases. Some dogs are gluttons and others will overeat when/if they are bored. (Like some people I know.)

Owners are not truly aware of the dog’s eating patterns. They may not notice that a dog has not eaten. If you have multiple dogs, one dog may eat excessively while the others do not get adequate nutrition. When dogs are fed at scheduled times it is easy to see if and how much they ate. Lack of appetite is usually the first indicator of illness.

Free feeding puppies can make house training a difficult and lengthy process as it is difficult to predict when the puppy eats and needs to go out.

Food may become less motivating when used in training. What makes you think that food you are offering makes you more interesting than that squirrel over there that needs chasing?

Free feeding only works with food, like kibble, that will not easily spoil when left out for a period of time. Also, leaving food out in the open might attract insects and other pests.

If you have multiple dogs and someone leaves you a “gift” in the hallway, how are you going to know who was the culprit? And even if you think you know who is the guilty party, it is too late to give any reasonable correction. Canine memories are short. You may think that your pooch looks or acts guilty upon your discovery of the “crime”. He is likely just responding to the anger that is radiating off you at that moment and really doesn’t have a clue why you are upset.

So back to my two tiny charges. They start their day with a 30 minute walk. Each does their doggie business. They get a 15 – 20 minute potty break at lunch time, another 30 minute walk before dinner and another 15 – 20 minute potty break before bed.

It ought to be safe to leave them, for a short time, in their pen on the lino floor with their day-bed, toys, food and water. This isn’t necessarily so. When I returned a mere 4 hours later one of them has left a “gift” on the lino. The first time this happened I was willing to put it down to anxiety (they’ve been left behind by their people and now there is this stranger) and the fact that my schedule is slightly different from that of their owners. The second time it happened I was thinking that they were not entirely trustworthy and that this is why they are penned rather than given the liberty of the house.

Now I watch them like a hawk because I suspect that they may sneak off into a corner or under a table and do something that I will not appreciate. When I let them off leash after their walk they charge through the house in the general direction of their pen. The third “gift” brought me to the conclusion that they are not really house-trained and that this free feeding method is what contributes to their (for me) unacceptable behavior.

Now the question is: do I put them on to a scheduled feeding time while I am taking care of them or not? What do you think? What would you do?

3 thoughts on “Double Trouble: or Why I think Free Feeding Dogs is a Questionable Practice.

  1. One I completely agree with all your misgivings about free feeding. There are just too many medical and behavioral problems that can arise and early health warning signs that are too easy to miss. As for the potty training, I never felt comfortable deviating from the owner’s instructions without their prior permission. Sometimes a truly catastrophic emergency would require a change in plans without talking to the owners first, but generally my own inclination is to follow the guideline of “their house, their dogs, their rules.” That being said, if you could get a hold of them, maybe they’d have some advice or insight. Possibly they forgot to tell you something, or maybe the dogs where crate trained when they were puppies and the owners would allow you to return to crating until the potty issue subsides. Not matter what, it’s an unpleasant business. I feel for you!


    • Thank you Audrey. It is frequently awkward taking care of another person’s fur-babies. I agree with your “their house, their dogs, their rules” and will continue in that vein. I just find it frustrating to have to deal with the mess. On the up-side at least they have happened on an easily cleaned floor. 🙂 The dogs are confined whenever they cannot be directly supervised. The owners deal with this daily. I think a part of me is still incredulous that someone is willing to just accept this behavior.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Dog Rules

The Dog Rules

Once the proud guardian of a rather cheeky Border Collie/Aussie Cattle Dog mix, may she forever rest in peace, my favourite activities were those things that included my canine friend. Now I have a new canine buddy in my life. He's also a Border Collie and sassy like my girl was. We're in the middle of an adventure; teaching him how to be a good canine citizen I spend my spare time volunteering at the local animal shelter as a dog walker/trainer. You can read all about it @

View Full Profile →


Blog Stats

  • 2,806 hits
Blogging U.
The Science Dog

By Linda P. Case

Work less, Live More

Technology Solutions to Do More, Faster, and Better

Weeds an All

Slugs and Snails, Successes and Fails. That's what my garden is made of.

Travel Taste Create

Join me as I explore, sample new food & drink, and celebrate creativity.

Poor Robert's (Wine) Almanac

Fun Stuff and Facts about Wine

Tippy Tales

Adventures of a rescue dog

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

98 Acres in Albany

40 Blocks, Thousands of Stories

YayYay's Kitchen

Feed the body well, nourish the soul, heal the Earth, build community, make peace, wreak joy

Ramblings of a Writer

Living the Path of Life


Enjoy The Journey

So Far From

Where I Began

Olive These Words

"One of the secrets of life is that all that is really worth the doing is what we do for others." - Lewis Carroll

Mind and Life Matters

Your Life, Your Mind - It Matters!

the biology of belief

THINK beyond your genes...

The Blog

The latest news on and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: